BREAKING NEWS
Advertise with us >

Smoke inhalation blamed for newborn deaths in PIMS nursery fire

Smoke inhalation

ISLAMABAD: Newborns who died in a fire at the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences died from inhaling smoke and soot rather than from burns, PIMS Executive Director Rana Imran Sikandar said Friday.

Sikandar said the identities of the deceased infants were confirmed through identification tags on their wrists. He said the tags remained intact, making DNA testing unnecessary. DNA tests would have been required if the bodies had been unidentifiable, he said.

According to PIMS officials, 15 newborns were in the nursery when the fire broke out, while one infant was rescued. Hospital staff attempted to enter the nursery to save the babies, but the ceiling collapsed after an explosion, officials said.

Some relatives had expressed concerns over the identification of the deceased infants without DNA testing.

A day earlier, Dr. Shazia Sobia, a member of the National Assembly’s Standing Committee on Health, said she learned during a visit to PIMS that 40 to 50 babies, rather than 15, may have been present in the nursery. She questioned how the infants were handed over to their families without DNA testing.

Meanwhile, Pakistan’s National Assembly and Senate have called for a transparent investigation into the deaths of 14 newborns in a fire at the Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences, approving motions to form special parliamentary committees to investigate the incident.

Health Minister Mustafa Kamal assured lawmakers that no one responsible for the tragedy would be spared. He said all relevant officials would be held accountable and urged lawmakers not to intervene to protect officials facing disciplinary action.

Kamal also called on the opposition to provide guidance and a clear roadmap rather than limiting the response to dates and committee formations. He said practical solutions were needed to prevent similar tragedies in the future.

Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar said an investigation committee would submit its initial report to the prime minister on Friday, while a detailed report would be prepared within seven days. He said necessary action would be taken after the findings and urged lawmakers to offer concrete recommendations instead of politicizing the tragedy.

Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz Sen. Pervez Rashid proposed that senior government officials receive medical treatment at public hospitals. He said forming inquiry committees and issuing punishments alone would not improve the health care system.

Instead, he suggested that everyone drawing a government salary, including the president, prime minister, bureaucracy and judiciary, should use public hospitals to encourage improvements in those facilities.

Former National Assembly speaker Raja Pervez Ashraf said innocent children had died because of possible negligence and demanded that the facts be made public.

The opposition expressed a lack of confidence in the government’s committee investigating the PIMS incident. Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf Sen. Ali Zafar called for an inquiry committee headed by the opposition and demanded punishment for those responsible.

Senate opposition leader Raja Nasir Abbas described the PIMS incident as “murder” rather than negligence and alleged that the victims’ parents had been pressured. He called for accountability and a full disclosure of the facts surrounding the deaths.

Health Committee raises serious questions over PIMS nursery fire

Health Committee

ISLAMABAD: The National Assembly Standing Committee on Health has expressed dissatisfaction with explanations provided by Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences (PIMS) officials over the fire in the hospital’s neonatal nursery that killed newborns, calling for the suspension of doctors and staff on duty and advising Federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal to consider resigning on moral grounds.

After visiting the hospital, committee Chairman Dr. Mahesh Kumar said officials initially claimed the fire had started from an air conditioner, but it later emerged that the unit was not functioning.

“Yesterday they said the fire started from the air conditioner. Today we learned that the AC was not even working,” Mahesh Kumar said, adding that CCTV footage had also failed to establish how the fire started.

He said the committee would conduct its own investigation and questioned why newborns were being kept in a nursery built in 1990. According to him, infants should have been accommodated in the nursery of the newer block.

Committee member Dr. Shazia Thobia said the visit revealed that the nursery had 40 to 50 babies at the time, rather than the 15 initially reported. She also questioned how children were handed over to relatives without DNA testing.

Former Islamabad advocate general Jahangir Jadoon said a full investigation into the incident would not be possible without establishing a judicial commission.

Meanwhile, the Senate Standing Committee on Health has decided to hold its meeting at PIMS on Monday and invited Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf senators to attend.

PIMS Forms Four-Member Inquiry Committee

PIMS Executive Director has declined to resign on moral grounds, while the hospital administration has formed a four-member committee headed by Professor Dr. Atif Inam to investigate the fire.

The committee has been given 48 hours to submit its report. It will determine the cause of the fire, review fire-safety measures, assess the effectiveness and response time of the rescue operation, and identify those responsible while recommending disciplinary action.

PIMS Deputy Executive Director Dr. Aneesa Jalil is also a member of the committee. She recorded her statement before the prime minister’s inquiry committee earlier Thursday and also signed the notification establishing the hospital’s internal inquiry committee.

Prime Minister’s Committee Seeks Written Statements

Separately, the inquiry committee formed by Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has sought written statements from staff members of the Children’s Hospital nursery.

Sources said the committee took possession of the nursery’s CCTV record and questioned staff members. It also reviewed the footage and compared it with the hospital administration’s account of how the fire started.

The committee also questioned PIMS health management officials. Hospital administration submitted the duty roster of staff present on Aug. 26, while the fire brigade and emergency department provided their reports.

Four officials, including the joint executive director of PIMS, submitted written statements to the committee.

The prime minister’s inquiry committee is expected to submit an interim report within 48 hours.